Novazyme Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Novazyme Interview 21 May 2001
This is an approximate transcript (i.e. from notes, not a
tape) of an interview between Novazyme and the
International Pompe Association (IPA). The participants
were, from Novazyme: John Crowley (CEO), Julie Anne Smith
(Senior Director, Patient Advocacy), William Canfield,
M.D., Ph.D. (Chief Scientist), Pedro Huertas, M.D., Ph.D.
(Chief Medical Officer), Anthony McKinney (Vice
President, Drug Development) and from the IPA: Randall
House (AMDA) and Kevin O'Donnell (AGSD-UK). The
contributions are designated as IPA or Novazyme, rather
than to individuals, for the simple reason that everyone
contributed to the discussion and it was difficult to
keep track of who exactly said what!
What makes Novazyme different?
The people, culture and philosophy. We are a
science-driven, patient-focused organization. The patient
is at the center of everything we do.
We're a glycobiology company. We manipulate
carbohydrate structures - for example the sugar chains on
enzymes, which can be 50% of the volume of the active
enzyme. In order to treat lysosomal storage diseases
(LSDs), we need to be able to mimic the carbohydrate
structure of the natural enzyme.
Novazyme's expertise in this area stems from over 8 years
of research by Dr. William Canfield at the University of
Oklahoma.
The carbohydrate chains on lysosomal enzymes target the
enzymes to the cells that need it most (heart and
muscle). Phosphorylating those carbohydrates is the
signal that tells the cell to transport the enzyme inside
the lysosomes.
CHO (Chinese hamster ovary) cells, commonly used in cell
culture, have a tendency to modify carbohydrate chains in
a way that significantly reduces the efficacy of the
finished enzyme. They tend to add complex carbohydrate
chains rather than the mannose-6-phosphate residues
needed as markers for the lysosomes.
Novazyme is modifies the CHO product to make it more
natural.
How important is this tendency of CHO cells to
add complex carbohydrates? Hasn't the CHO product used in
the Duke trial worked well?
The standard in-vitro assay used to measure
enzyme uptake may give an exaggerated figure - because it
doesn't account for the way the liver can soak up that
enzyme when it is introduced to the body. Based on a
comparable enzyme we have produced, we estimate that less
than 1% of the enzyme used in the Duke trial is
phosphoryated.
What's the evidence for the efficacy of the
Novazyme product?
Animal studies carried out at Oklahoma and by
Dr. Barry Byrne at the University of Florida indicate
that normal enzyme activity could be restored to one
year-old Pompe's mice with just one injection of our
enzyme. It also clears massive amounts of glycogen from
the muscle cells after just 6 hours. This is a finding
that we have repeated several times.
The high activity of the enzyme means that we may be able
to achieve the above result with a lower dose of enzyme
than with either the CHO or transgenic products. Our
dosage in mice was 0.3mg/kg. The equivalent for the Duke
CHO enzyme is 10 mg/kg and for the transgenic enzyme 40
mg/kg.
Once enzyme activity is replaced, glycogen is cleared
from the muscles and muscle strength is restored. We have
measured muscle strength by an electrical method that
allows us to compare the strength of treated and
untreated muscle in mice.
This last finding is very important because it suggests
that muscles may recover after the glycogen is cleared.
The big question now is, can this be replicated in
humans?
What are your plans for clinical trials?
We intend to start a clinical trial towards the
end of 2001. It will involve affected children and take
place at three different centers in the USA Florida, NIH
Bethesda, Philadelphia). The trial will be designed so
that we can rapidly expand to international centers and
to pivotal Phase III as soon as possible.
How many children will you be including and what
will be the criteria for inclusion?
The trial will include 12-18 children. Our
approach to inclusion will be different to that taken in
other trials. We will take profoundly ill children and
attempt to make them better.
Just to be clear, by 'profoundly ill' do you mean
children who are already showing symptoms of Pompe's and
who may be, for example, ventilator dependent?
The two things we want our trials to do are to
contribute to science and to help patients. We will
therefore be looking at patients with symptoms and will
not be excluding children on ventilators. We will be
looking for children who have the cardinal manifestations
of the disease - cardiac dysfunction (which we believe is
in all types, not just the infantile, though not in the
form of cardiomyopathy), pulmonary involvement and
musculo-skeletal disorder. It doesn't matter which age
the children are, as long as they meet the criteria.
However, we don't know what the exact criteria will be
until we meet with the FDA.
Will the trial be restricted to children in the
USA?
The trial will be open to all children who meet
the trial criteria, anywhere in the world. We believe
that costs should not be something that families should
have to worry about, so we will meet all traveling and
accommodation expenses, and also compensate for loss of
earnings.
Will any of the children on the trial be given a
placebo?
No. We are looking for a striking improvement
that will demonstrate the efficacy of the treatment. We
are looking to reverse the disorder, not just halt
decline. We believe that we understand enough about the
disease to be able to show change without comparison to a
placebo. We also think that it would be unethical to
bring children into the trial - perhaps involving a great
deal of domestic upheaval - and give them a placebo.
So what are the next steps after that initial
trial - will you be extending to other sub-types?
We don't believe that there are sub-classes of
Pompe's - what we have is a continuum. However patients
can be grouped into distinct populations and we will hold
pivotal phase III trials aimed at those populations. We
are currently in discussion with the regulatory agencies
to that effect.
The big distinction is between CRIM (cross-reactive
immunological material) -ve individuals and CRIM +ves.
All those with the classical infantile form are CRIM -ve,
meaning that they may produce antibodies against
alpha-glucosidase. It is possible that the lower dosages
needed with our enzyme may help reduce this problem.
The target for the start of wider trials is mid 2002. Our
intention is to run different trials in parallel. We are
looking worldwide for trial sites, including Australia
and Europe.
What is the bottleneck for progress?
We need commercial grade material for phase III
and we are looking at options for this. We may decide to
manufacture in-house. All of these things are progressing
in parallel - we are not waiting for the results of Phase
I/II before making progress with Phase III.
When do you think you will be able to complete
the registration process?
The best case for approval is mid-2003. This is
a challenging target. However building a company from
scratch in a year was equally challenging - and we did
it!
What about pricing? The high cost of ERT is a
concern for many people.
Our philosophy on pricing is that the patient is
at the center. The cost will reflect the burden of the
disease. We recognize that this is a life-saving
technology and our intention is that it will be fairly
priced relative to other products in this area. This will
be partly due to the low dosages required.
Our philosophy is that no patient should be deprived of
this drug because they can't afford it.
What about the developing world?
We will look at ways of tackling the problem of
provision in the developing world. To be honest, we would
love to have that problem. Our core philosophy of
providing the best drug to as many patients as quickly as
possible applies with equal vigor to all patients,
regardless of geography.
We are determined to retain our patient focus, despite
the competing pressures of Wall Street, the regulatory
authorities etc. That is why we have appointed Julie Anne
Smith as Senior Director with responsibility for
Patient Advocacy.
What is your attitude to the patient groups?
Our philosophy is to be open and honest and to
build a partnership. We have already spoken directly to
over 100 patients. If there is any change in the
timetable we've outlined in this interview, you'll hear
it first from us.
Our focus is that it will be great to treat 12-18 kids -
but what we need to do is to treat 12-18 hundred kids.
How independent is Novazyme? Is there any chance
that you will 'do a Synpac'?
We will do whatever gets our treatment to as
many patients as possible, as fast as possible. At the
moment, we've considered whether that could best be done
as part of a collaboration and have come to the view
that, in fact, the best way is to be independent.
However, that decision is constantly being re-evaluated
against our patient-centered philosophy.
Although 95% of our efforts are currently directed at
Pompe's, we have plans for other products. We are also
developing treatments for other LSDs - MSP I, Gaucher,
and Fabry disease.
Gaucher disease? You're really planning to
compete with Genzyme's big product?
The decision isn't driven by a desire to go head
to head with Genzyme. We believe that we have a product
which will be an improvement on Cerezyme (the Genzyme ERT
for Gaucher) and which may help patients with
difficulties that product does not help.
What's your biggest problem at present?
Our biggest challenge is putting all the
parallel strands together and holding them together. Four
months ago we didn't have a manufacturing plant. Now we
have a state of the art plant, operators, a GMP (good
manufacturing practice) team etc.
We believe that we may well have the "Holy
Grail" necessary to effectively treat this horrid
disease. We believe that we can beat Nature. But now we
have to deliver it to patients. We are a 80-person
company going at 100 miles per hour, trying to satisfy
our Directors, Wall Street, the regulators - while all
the time keeping our patient focus.
What effect does John Crowley's background have
on the company?
John Crowley's background undoubtedly helps in
retaining and strengthening focus. We want to help not
just Megan and Patrick but the thousands of children like
them.
We have a regular 'Lunch and Learn' feature where we
bring in patients to talk to the staff here about their
experience of Pompe's and that also helps to retain the
patient focus.
For the record though, Megan and Patrick Crowley will not
necessarily take part in the first clinical trial. John
Crowley is standing aside from that process.
That means that we are not letting up from our drive to
make the enzyme as widely available as possible, as
quickly as possible. We will be looking to set up an
expanded access program [AKA compassionate use - KO'D] as
early as possible in the trials. Participants would need
to follow the established treatment protocol and their
data could therefore contribute to the approval process.
Thank you for the open way you have approached
these discussions and for the time you have devoted to
them. We look forward to working with you in the future.
And AMDA wants to thank Kevin O'Donnell
for giving his time and energy once again to promote the
Pompe cause. Thank you Kevin!
Novazyme
Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Unprecedented Response to
Enzyme Therapy for Pompe Disease in Mouse Model
Preliminary Data Suggest
Complete Restoration of Skeletal Muscle Function Signals
Potential Therapy for Rare Form of Muscular Dystrophy
Orlando, Florida, April 2, 2001 -
Researchers from the University of Florida, in
conjunction with Novazyme Pharmaceuticals, Inc., (http://www.novazyme.com), demonstrated for the first time that a
specially engineered, recombinant human enzyme restores
normal muscle function in laboratory animals with a rare
type of muscular dystrophy called Pompe disease. Pompe
disease is caused by a deficiency of the enzyme acid
alpha-glucosidase (GAA), which breaks down glycogen.
NZ-1001 or highly phosphorylated recombinant human acid
alpha-glucosidase (HP-rhGAA), the modified GAA developed
and produced by Novazyme Pharmaceuticals, Inc.,
successfully treated experimental mice engineered to have
Pompe disease. The investigators treated animals with two
separate doses, one week apart resulting in restoration
of normal levels of GAA to both skeletal and cardiac
muscles, the organs most affected by the disease. NZ-1001
also cleared accumulated glycogen from the muscles of
these mice. Most importantly, treatment with NZ-1001
restored normal skeletal muscle function in these
diseased mice.
Utilizing Novazyme's proprietary technologies, the
company has developed a recombinant human GAA that is
nearly identical to the enzyme present in healthy
persons. The GAA is produced in a complex process that
adds phosphate and modifies sugar molecules attached to
the enzyme. The modifications enable the enzyme to be
effectively targeted to the lysosome, the location within
the muscle cells where it is needed to work.
Barry Byrne, M.D., Ph.D., a pediatric
cardiologist in the Departments of Pediatrics, Molecular
Genetics and Microbiology and Associate Director of the
Powell Gene Therapy Center at the University of Florida,
presented the data at the Experimental Biology 2001
conference sponsored by the Federation of American
Societies for Experimental Biology (FASEB) - one the
world's largest meetings for basic science researchers.
"These studies indicate that NZ-1001 reaches
affected organs, enters the target cells, clears
accumulated glycogen and restores function in affected
animals." said Barry Byrne, M.D. Ph.D.
Pompe disease is a rare, fatal, genetic disorder caused
by a deficiency of the enzyme, acid alpha-glucosidase
(GAA). Without this enzyme, glycogen accumulates in the
lysosome of cells and rapidly destroys muscle fibers.
Patients with Pompe disease experience severe muscle
weakness, difficulty breathing and cardiac insufficiency.
Ultimately, patients require wheel chair assistance and
mechanical ventilation and succumb to cardiopulmonary
failure. There is currently no approved therapy for Pompe
disease.
President and CEO of Novazyme, John F. Crowley said,
"We are delighted with the results reported by Dr.
Byrne. The data demonstrates that phosphorylation
combined with proper glycosylation is critical to reach
target tissues in this cruel disease. If we can replicate
these results in Pompe patients, we expect a dramatic
improvement in their muscle function that, hopefully,
will halt and perhaps even reverse the progression of the
disease and lead to measurable improvements in quality of
life. Novazyme will move NZ-1001 rapidly forward into
human clinical trials later this year." ........
Novazyme
Pharmaceuticals Receives Orphan Drug Designation for
Pompe Disease Therapy
Company to pursue Pompe
disease treatment as first in pipeline of drugs to treat
lysosomal storage disorders
Oklahoma City, OK, October 5, 2000 -
Novazyme Pharmaceuticals, Inc. today announced that the
Company has received formal notification from the Office
of Orphan Products Development at the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) that its proprietary, highly
phosphorylated enzyme replacement therapy for the
treatment of Pompe Disease has been granted orphan drug
status. This notification from the FDA represents the
first official validation of Novazyme's core
phosphorylation technology platform with which the
Company intends to address the unmet needs of lysosomal
storage disease (LSD) patients.
Pompe disease is a fatal neuromuscular disease for which
there is currently no approved therapy. Pompe is one of
49 LSDs characterized by the absence of enzymes in the
lysosomes of the body's cells. There are several subtypes
of Pompe disease that affect persons from infancy to
adulthood. All forms of the disease, however, are fatal.
There are approximately 5,000-10,000 Pompe patients in
the developed world, making it one of the most prevalent
of the 49 known LSDs.
In its application for orphan status, filed on July 14,
2000, Novazyme submitted pre-clinical evidence
demonstrating that its highly phosphorylated product for
Pompe disease, designated as NZ-1001, provides greatly
enhanced enzyme uptake into affected cells. Enhanced
enzyme uptake is widely viewed as the key to the
treatment of all lysosomal storage diseases, particularly
Pompe's. With more efficient uptake of replacement
enzymes, patients may benefit by greater response to
these therapies and by reduced side effects, such as
antibody responses.
The company's filing also highlighted the fundamentally
different molecular structure of a lysosomal enzyme
replacement therapy that is highly phosphorylated and
that lacks complex carbohydrate structures. The FDA
notification specifically stated that: "We have
determined that [Novazyme's] recombinant human highly
phosphorylated acid alpha-glucosidase (rhHPGAA) qualifies
for orphan designation for enzyme replacement therapy in
patients with all subtypes of glycogen storage disease
type II [Pompe Disease]."
"The Orphan designation is an important step forward
in our path to the human clinic and in providing this
treatment to the patients with no current alternative. We
are especially proud to have effectively advanced the
development of this technology and to have achieved this
level of regulatory recognition so efficiently,"
commented Dr. William Canfield, Novazyme founder and
Chief Scientific Officer.
Orphan drug designation qualifies Novazyme to receive
certain benefits such as tax credits and marketing
exclusivity from the Government in exchange for
developing HPGAA. The FDA may grant orphan drug
designation to drugs intended to treat a rare disease or
condition. If approved, the FDA may not approve any other
applications to market the same drug for the same
indication except in very limited circumstances for seven
years.
"With this acknowledgement from the FDA, we are
confident that we are well-positioned to move our
proprietary technologies rapidly into the human clinic on
multiple diseases and to take a leadership position in
this therapeutic field," stated Anthony McKinney,
Vice President for Drug Development.
"If Novazyme's enzyme therapy for Pompe Disease
proves effective, this would bring enormous benefits to
many Pompe patients worldwide who are in such desperate
need for a therapy to relieve their life-threatening
disease," stated, Dr. Alfred Slonim, Director of the
Pompe Disease Center at North Shore University Hospital
in Manhasset, New York and an Associate Professor of
Pediatrics at New York University.
Novazyme is a pharmaceutical company developing
biotherapies for the treatment of lysosomal storage
disorders. These biotherapies are based on Novazyme's
proprietary technologies for the targeted delivery of the
missing enzymes critical for the treatment of these
diseases. The technologies were developed by William M.
Canfield, M.D., Ph.D. in his laboratories at the
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center. Dr.
Canfield, an Associate Professor of Medicine at the
university, founded Novazyme in 1999. Dr. Canfield
currently serves as the company's chairman and chief
scientific officer. Novazyme's headquarters are located
in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma. The company's principal
investors include: Catalyst Health & Technology
Partners (Boston); HealthCare Ventures (Princeton); the
Perseus-Soros Biopharmaceutical Fund (New York); and
Neose Technologies (NasdaqNM: NTEC).
CONTACT:
Novazyme Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
John F. Crowley President & Chief Executive Officer
(609) 844-7570; E-mail: jcrowley@novazyme.com
Noonan/Russo
Stephen Gendel Vice President
(212) 696-4455; E-mail: s.gendel@noonanrusso.com
|